On Harmony and Art "Rules"

I realized I had to blog today. And I juggled my lack of inspiration against the stack of my harmony student's work that still needs to be marked and sent back. And then I thought of my own journey through the harmony textbooks. In Grade 9, while I was struggling to remember and follow all the rules, my Grade 9 teacher said, "Yeah, and then you get into studying music history, and you discover that all the famous composers ever did was break the rules anyways." That discouraged me. Why was I learning this stuff if it didn't matter? If no one regarded it? If the rules were only there for the exam and nothing more? In Grade 10, I silently carried this attitude over to my new theory teacher. She didn't reprimand it. Maybe, because I was the silent and obliging type, she didn't even notice it. Instead she took me to her piano. She made me play the wrong harmonies, the rule-breakers. Then she had ...